Question of the Week: I Inherited a Home Near Canyon Lake. Should I Keep It or Sell It?
By Steve & Betty Giannone
Every week I answer a real question from a buyer or seller here in the Hill Country, and this one arrives more often than people expect: "I inherited a home near Canyon Lake. Should I keep it or sell it?" It usually comes at the same time as a lot of other emotions, and it deserves a straight answer. The good news is that the tax picture is friendlier than most people fear, and the market picture is clearer than it looks from a Zillow page. Let me walk you through what the current numbers say and how I help families make this decision.
What Does the Market Around Canyon Lake Look Like Right Now?
Let's start with the honest market truth, because it shapes every other decision. Canyon Lake's 78133 ZIP is running about 14.6 months of housing supply, nearly three times the roughly 5.1-month national average, which is why it ranked No. 7 on a 2026 national list of America's strongest buyer's markets. The median sold price has run roughly $395,000 over the six months through October, values are down a few percent from a year ago, and homes are averaging around 100 days to sell.
What that means for an inherited property is straightforward: if you sell, do it with realistic pricing and some patience, because the buyers you need are out there but they are not in a hurry. It also means the home is worth less on paper today than it was a few years ago, so selling right now is a "life decision," not a windfall. For a family deciding whether to keep the home, that same soft market has an upside: if you buy out a sibling or refinance, mortgage rates just fell for a third straight week to 7.18% in the week ending November 5, per Freddie Mac, down from 7.40% in early October.
Do You Owe Taxes When You Inherit or Sell?
This is the part that puts most families at ease. Texas has no state inheritance tax and no state estate tax. Texas repealed its inheritance tax back in 2015, and voters added a constitutional ban on any future estate, inheritance, or other death tax in November 2025. The federal estate tax only applies to very large estates, currently around $14 million and up, and it is paid by the estate, not by you as an heir. For a typical Hill Country home, this is simply not a factor.
Even the federal capital gains picture is kinder than most people assume, thanks to the stepped-up basis. Under federal tax law, the home's tax basis resets to its fair market value on the date of the original owner's death. That means all the appreciation that built up during their lifetime is effectively erased for tax purposes, and you only owe capital gains on any increase in value after you inherited it. Since Texas is a community property state, both halves of a married couple's home get that stepped-up basis when the first spouse passes. For most inherited Hill Country homes sold within a year or two, the taxable gain is small or zero. You will still want to confirm the numbers with a tax professional, because every family situation is different, but the fear of a huge tax bill is usually the biggest misunderstanding I clear up.
What About Property Taxes on an Inherited Home?
This is where an inherited home can surprise people, and it is worth checking early. Property tax exemptions do not automatically transfer when an owner passes. The homestead exemption and the over-65 exemption end when the original owner dies, and the cap that limits annual appraisal increases can fall away, which can push the taxable value up to full market value.
The fix is simple and proactive: talk to the county appraisal district soon after you inherit. If you move into the home yourself, you can apply for the residence homestead exemption on the home you actually live in. A surviving spouse 55 or older may be able to continue the deceased spouse's over-65 exemption. And under a 2019 Texas law, family members who live in an inherited home can claim the homestead exemption even before the deed or probate is finished. None of this happens automatically, so put it on your list early, and the property tax bill will not come as a shock.
Should You Rent It Out Instead of Selling?
Renting is a real option, but the Hill Country rental rules take some homework. Canyon Lake itself is unincorporated Comal County, so there is no countywide short-term rental permit program, but the county treats a rental conversion as a change in use for septic purposes, which means the number of guests has to match the septic capacity. Local taxing districts apply a lodging tax to short stays, Texas adds its state hotel occupancy tax, and, most importantly, many lakeside POAs and HOAs have deed restrictions that limit or ban rentals altogether. In nearby New Braunfels, short-term rentals are prohibited in residential zoning districts, so that option is off the table for many in-town properties.
None of this means renting is impossible. It means you need to verify the rules for that specific property before you count on rental income to carry the home. If a long-term lease makes more sense, that is usually a simpler path, but it still comes with property management, maintenance, and the responsibility of being a landlord from possibly another state. I have walked many families through these trade-offs, and the right answer depends entirely on the property and your situation.
Keep It or Sell It: How Do You Decide?
Here is the decision framework I use with families, and it applies whether you inherited a lake house in Canyon Lake, a place near Wimberley, or a family home in New Braunfels. First, will you actually use it? If you and your family will spend real time there, keeping it can be a gift that outlasts any spreadsheet. If nobody will use it, the carrying costs decide the question. Second, can the heirs agree? A buyout or a clear agreement about who pays taxes, insurance, and upkeep prevents more family conflict than almost anything else. Third, what do the carrying costs look like? Property taxes, insurance, HOA dues, and maintenance add up on a second property, especially one you do not live in full time.
And fourth, look at the market honestly. Right now a sale will take around 100 days and require realistic pricing, but it also lets you walk away with cash and no ongoing responsibility. If you do decide to sell, get a professional valuation from someone who knows lake and Hill Country property, not just an online estimate. Those sites do not understand what a waterfront parcel, a septic system, or a flood zone does to value, and neither should your decision.
“An inherited home is never just a financial asset. It is full of memories, and it deserves a decision you can live with for years. My job is to give you the market truth, the tax picture, and a straight answer, so you can decide with your head and your heart in agreement.”
Why Talk This Through With Someone Local?
Because the difference between a good outcome and a regret is almost always in the details: what the property is really worth in a 14.6-month-supply market, how the tax basis and exemptions apply to your family, whether the home can be rented under its HOA rules, and how to handle a sale when there are multiple heirs. After nearly four decades in the Central Texas Hill Country, including a background in mortgage banking, I have helped families work through inherited properties across Canyon Lake, Wimberley, New Braunfels, and everywhere in between. I will give you a straight answer about whether to keep or sell, and if you sell, I will help you do it well.
Steve Giannone has spent nearly four decades helping buyers and sellers across the Central Texas Hill Country, with a special focus on lake homes, inherited and estate properties, retirement living, and relocation. He is a licensed Texas real estate salesperson (License #0584260) with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Don Johnson Realtors, and he is available 24/7 for questions about Canyon Lake, Wimberley, New Braunfels, San Antonio, Austin, and anywhere across the Hill Country.
Have a real estate question of your own? Ask Steve anytime on the Ask Steve page below, and I will do my best to answer it in a future Question of the Week. No question is too small, and Steve is available 24/7 for the questions that cannot wait.
Wondering whether to keep or sell an inherited Hill Country home?
Steve is available 24/7. Call or text 512-751-2628 any time.
Ask Steve & Betty
Have a Hill Country question? We're here 24/7.
Ask Steve & BettyIt's always a good time to buy or sell in the Hill Country.