Question of the Week: Should I Take My Home Off the Market for the Holidays?
By Steve & Betty Giannone
Every week I answer a real question from a buyer or seller here in the Hill Country, and this one is showing up in nearly every conversation I have right now: "Should I take my home off the market for the holidays?" It is a fair question, and this time of year almost every seller thinks it. The honest answer depends on your situation, so let me lay out what the current numbers say and how I walk my own clients through the decision.
Why Is This Question Everywhere This Week?
Because the calendar has turned, and sellers are watching their listing sit. If you have a home on the market around Canyon Lake or Wimberley right now, you already know the feeling: showings slow down, weekends fill with errands instead of open houses, and family starts asking what the plan is. So the question becomes, do I keep paying to carry this listing through Thanksgiving and Christmas, or do I take it down and try again in the spring?
I understand the instinct. But the decision should come from data, not from frustration, and the data in this market points somewhere most sellers do not expect.
What Do the Numbers Say About Selling Right Now?
Start with the reality of the current market. Canyon Lake's 78133 ZIP is running about 14.6 months of supply, nearly triple the roughly 5.1-month national average, which is why it ranked No. 7 on a 2026 national list of America's strongest buyer's markets. Homes there are taking roughly 102 days to sell, and many sellers are settling near 97% of their list price. Wimberley tells a similar story with about 11.4 months of supply and a median around 104 days on market. Closer in, the San Antonio-New Braunfels metro holds about six months of supply with homes averaging around 88 to 90 days, and the Austin metro sits near 5.4 months of inventory.
Here is the key point: this market was slow before the holidays arrived. A home that is not selling in October was not going to sell any faster in December because of the calendar alone. Taking your home off the market for a month or two does not change the supply sitting across the lake and down the valley. It just pauses your own exposure while everything else stays exactly where it was.
What Really Happens When You Take a Home Off the Market?
Three things, and none of them help you. First, you lose the buyers who are searching right now, including the out-of-state buyers who fly in to visit family over the holidays and tack on a house tour while they are here. That is a real group in Central Texas, where so many buyers are relocating, retiring, or buying a second home from out of state.
Second, you restart the clock in a way that matters to buyers. When you list again in February or March, the first thing an agent pulls up is the listing history. A fresh listing that sold quickly reads as priced right. A home that was on the market for a few months, disappeared, then came back has to answer for that pause, and in a buyer's market, it almost always costs you leverage.
Third, you give up the winter window entirely. Spring brings the biggest wave of new listings in the Hill Country. If you re-list then, you are not joining a smaller field, you are joining the biggest, most competitive crowd of the year, right as more supply pushes against already-high months of inventory. The home that struggled at 14 months of supply in the fall will be competing against even more in the spring.
Who Is Actually Buying in the Hill Country During the Holidays?
More people than you might think, and they tend to be the serious ones. The buyers I am working with right now are relocating for a job that starts in January, retirees closing on a home in one state to free up money for one here, and second-home buyers who want to be on Canyon Lake by the new year. These are not tire-kickers. They have deadlines, financing in place, and a reason to move, and a holiday calendar does not change that.
Mortgage rates are also part of the context. The average 30-year fixed rate was 7.32% in the week ending October 22, 2026, per Freddie Mac, down from 7.40% the two weeks before. Rates are still high enough to keep some buyers on the sidelines, which is exactly why the buyers who are out there matter. Fewer lookers, but the ones who look are ready to make a decision.
If You Keep It Listed, What Should You Fix Before Thanksgiving?
If you are going to stay on the market through the holidays, do not just sit there hoping. Use the next few weeks to do the things that actually move a home in a buyer's market:
- Revisit the price. Price is the single biggest lever. In a market where homes are selling near 97% of list, an overpriced home is simply not getting shown. A realistic price now beats a hopeful price in March.
- Refresh your photos and staging. If your listing photos are from August, retake them. Bright, welcoming photos of a warm, inviting home are the first thing buyers see in a long winter search.
- Make the home easy to show. Buyers are on tight schedules over the holidays. Be flexible with showing times, keep the house ready, and say yes to weekend and evening appointments.
- Add tasteful, not overwhelming, holiday touches. Warm lighting and a simple wreath make a home feel lived-in. Over-the-top decor makes buyers struggle to picture their own stuff in it.
- Watch the market, not the calendar. If a comparable sells, adjust. The home that sells in a buyer's market is the one that responds to what the market is doing, not the one that waits it out.
When Does It Actually Make Sense to Pull a Listing?
There are honest reasons to take a home off the market, and I would not tell you otherwise. If the home needs real repairs and you want to do them before showing it again, that is a good reason. If you have decided to make a major price change and a fresh start will let you market it differently, that can work. And if you simply cannot keep the house show-ready through the holidays because of work or family, protect your sanity. But if you are pulling it just because it is slow, ask yourself this: slow is the market you are in, and it will still be here in the spring.
The sellers who do well in this market treat the holidays as an opportunity, not an excuse. Fewer competing listings means more of the attention of the buyers who are out there. I have seen more than one Hill Country home go under contract between Thanksgiving and New Year's because it was the one that stayed visible while others stepped aside.
“A buyer's market does not take the holidays off, and neither should a serious seller. The homes that sell are the ones that stay in front of the buyers who are actually looking. If your price and presentation are right, the holidays can be one of the quietest, most effective times to sell in the Hill Country.”
Why Get an Honest Read on Your Own Listing?
Every listing tells a different story, and a general answer only gets you so far. What your home needs might be a pricing conversation, a presentation refresh, or simply an honest assessment of how it compares to the other 14 months of supply around it. After nearly four decades in this market, including a background in mortgage banking, I have seen every version of this decision play out, and I will give you a straight answer about whether staying listed makes sense for your home and your goals.
Steve Giannone has spent nearly four decades helping buyers and sellers across the Central Texas Hill Country, with a special focus on lake homes, retirement living, and relocation. He is a licensed Texas real estate salesperson (License #0584260) with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Don Johnson Realtors, and he is available 24/7 for questions about Canyon Lake, Wimberley, New Braunfels, San Antonio, Austin, and anywhere across the Hill Country.
Have a real estate question of your own? Ask Steve anytime on the Ask Steve page below, and I will do my best to answer it in a future Question of the Week. No question is too small, and Steve is available 24/7 for the questions that cannot wait.
Wondering whether your listing should stay live through the holidays?
Steve is available 24/7. Call or text 512-751-2628 any time.
Ask Steve & Betty
Have a Hill Country question? We're here 24/7.
Ask Steve & BettyIt's always a good time to buy or sell in the Hill Country.