Question of the Week: Is a Second Home in the Texas Hill Country Worth It?
By Steve & Betty Giannone
Every week I answer a real question from a buyer or seller here in the Hill Country, and this one keeps coming up from folks in Dallas, Houston, California, and Colorado: "Is a second home in the Texas Hill Country worth it?" It is a fair question, and the honest answer is that right now, for the right buyer, it may be the best opportunity we have seen in years. Let me show you what the current numbers say and what I tell my own clients to think through before they commit.
Why Are Second-Home Buyers Asking This Right Now?
Because the market has quietly turned in their favor. Canyon Lake's 78133 ZIP is running about 14.6 months of supply, which is nearly triple the roughly 5.1-month national average and why it ranked No. 7 on a 2026 national list of America's strongest buyer's markets. Wimberley holds about 11.4 months of supply. That means buyers have choices, sellers are motivated, and there is real room to negotiate on price, terms, and closing help. In nearly four decades in this market, I have rarely seen a better window for someone buying a place to enjoy, not flip.
At the same time, the lifestyle pull has never been stronger. People want a slice of the Hill Country: a lake house on Canyon Lake, a quiet place on the Blanco River near Wimberley, or a weekend home between New Braunfels and San Antonio. The lake is near full, the rivers are running, and the pace of life here is exactly what a second home is supposed to give you.
What Do the Current Numbers Say About the Market?
The data tells a consistent story across the region. In Canyon Lake's 78133 ZIP, the median sold price has run roughly $395,000 over the past six months, with values down a few percent from a year ago and homes taking around 100 days to sell. In Wimberley, the median sale price sits near $489,000, up about 10% year over year, with homes averaging roughly 104 days on market. New Braunfels comes in lower, around $347,000 to $386,000 depending on the source, with about 6.5 months of supply, a more balanced market.
Zoom out and the same pattern holds. The San Antonio-New Braunfels metro reported a median sale price of about $303,000 with roughly six months of inventory and 88 days on market in September. The Austin-Round Rock-San Marcos metro held a median of about $421,000 with 5.4 months of inventory. None of these are panic markets, but they are all markets where a patient buyer with financing in place has the upper hand, especially in the lake and river corridors where inventory is deepest.
How Do Second-Home Mortgage Rates Compare Right Now?
This is the part most people do not expect. The average 30-year fixed rate for a primary home was 7.24% in the week ending October 29, 2026, per Freddie Mac, down from 7.32% the week before and 7.40% earlier in October. Second-home loans cost more: lenders typically price them about 0.25% to 0.75% higher than a primary residence, and recent averages for a well-qualified second-home buyer have run near 7.9%. Plan on a larger down payment too, usually 10% to 20%.
Here is the thing about rates: they matter, but they are not the whole story. In a buyer's market with 14.6 months of supply, you can often negotiate a price concession or seller-paid closing costs that offset a good portion of the rate difference. A home bought a few percent under list, with closing help, can look very different on paper than the same home bought at full price. I walk every second-home buyer through that math before we ever write an offer.
What Should You Know Before Renting Out a Hill Country Second Home?
Many second-home buyers picture renting the place out when they are not using it, and that is where the fine print lives. Short-term rental rules in the Hill Country are local, and they vary street by street. The City of Canyon Lake prohibits short-term vacation rentals inside the city limits, with fines up to $1,500 per violation. New Braunfels restricts them in residentially zoned areas. In unincorporated Comal County there is no blanket ban, but you still need to satisfy septic, floodplain, HOA, and utility requirements, and Texas applies a 6% hotel occupancy tax to rentals of $15 or more per day.
None of this means renting is impossible. It means you need to verify the rules for the specific property before you count on rental income to carry the mortgage. I have seen buyers fall in love with a house, then discover the rental math does not work in that jurisdiction. That is exactly the kind of surprise I help people avoid, because it is far easier to check before you buy than to unwind after.
How Do You Decide If a Second Home Makes Sense for You?
Start with how you will actually use it, not with the investment math. A second home in the Hill Country makes the most sense when you will genuinely be here: weekends on the lake, holidays with family, a place to retire into later, or a home base for the years when the kids are grown. If you will visit twice a year, the numbers rarely work as well as a good rental or a hotel. If you will be here a dozen weekends a year and plan to keep the place long term, this market gives you a rare chance to buy well.
Then run the full cost picture: mortgage at a second-home rate, higher insurance for lake or river property, property taxes, HOA dues, maintenance on a place you do not live in full time, and any rental-related costs. In a buyer's market, the purchase price is often the easiest part to negotiate. The carrying costs are what you need to be honest about.
“A second home in the Hill Country is not a get-rich-quick play, and it should never be sold that way. It is a lifestyle decision with real financial upside when you buy well. With the deepest inventory in years and motivated sellers, the buyers who do their homework have a genuine advantage right now.”
Why Talk Through the Numbers With Me?
Because the difference between a good second-home buy and a regret is almost always in the details: which areas allow rentals, what lake access really means, how floodplain and insurance change the cost, and what a fair offer looks like in a 14.6-month-supply market. After nearly four decades in this market, including a background in mortgage banking, I have helped buyers from across the country find their place on Canyon Lake, the Blanco River, and everywhere in between. I will give you a straight answer about whether a second home makes sense for your situation, and if it does, I will help you buy it well.
Steve Giannone has spent nearly four decades helping buyers and sellers across the Central Texas Hill Country, with a special focus on lake homes, second homes, retirement living, and relocation. He is a licensed Texas real estate salesperson (License #0584260) with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Don Johnson Realtors, and he is available 24/7 for questions about Canyon Lake, Wimberley, New Braunfels, San Antonio, Austin, and anywhere across the Hill Country.
Have a real estate question of your own? Ask Steve anytime on the Ask Steve page below, and I will do my best to answer it in a future Question of the Week. No question is too small, and Steve is available 24/7 for the questions that cannot wait.
Wondering whether a Hill Country second home makes sense for you?
Steve is available 24/7. Call or text 512-751-2628 any time.
Ask Steve & Betty
Have a Hill Country question? We're here 24/7.
Ask Steve & BettyIt's always a good time to buy or sell in the Hill Country.